HEAT Leaders Blast Speaker Pelosi’s PAYGO Elimination

January 5, 2021
Press Release

WASHINGTON, D.C.—House Energy Action Team co-chairs Rep. Jeff Duncan (R-S.C.) and Rep. Markwayne Mullin (R-Okla.) joined House Republican Whip Steve Scalise (R-La.) in a joint statement to blast Speaker Pelosi’s rules package that exempts certain legislation from PAYGO requirements, laying the groundwork for multi-trillion-dollar, budget-busting bills like the Green New Deal without proper scrutiny or accounting for the damage they would do to hardworking families:
“Speaker Pelosi’s rules package prioritizes progressive activists over the livelihoods of the American people. By exempting certain legislation from PAYGO requirements, Speaker Pelosi and her socialist allies are paving the way for their radical Green New Deal without proper consideration of the devastating consequences it would have on American families. 
“The Democrats’ Green New Deal inspired agenda would outlaw fossil fuels and destroy American jobs, increase energy costs on hard-working families, and make our country less secure by increasing our dependence on oil from Russia and Middle-Eastern countries. Instead of acknowledging these facts, Speaker Pelosi created a rules package that would hide the devastating consequences of their legislation and require us to pass the bill to know how much it costs.
“This is an affront to middle-class families, American workers, our friends and allies overseas, and the all-of-the-above energy strategy that led to a cleaner environment along with the strongest economy our nation has ever seen. By supporting Speaker Pelosi’s rules package, every Democrat in Congress has displayed their contempt for working class Americans and their fundamental misunderstanding of what our country needs right now.” 

  • The traditional energy sector employs roughly 6.8 million Americans and added over 120,000 new jobs in 2019 alone.
  • The U.S. Chamber of Commerce found that a fracking ban imposed in 2021 would eliminate 19 million jobs and reduce U.S. GDP by $7 trillion in just four years.
  • According to a report by the Global Energy Institute, "keep it in the ground" activism, including New York State's ban on fracking, has prevented over $91 billion in economic activity and ruined 700,000 job opportunities.
  • The American Petroleum Institute (API) estimates a fracking ban would raise the cost of farming wheat (64%), corn (54%), and soybeans (48%).
  • Other estimates show that a 100% renewable energy grid would cost Americans anywhere from 43 to 286% more on their electricity bills. 
  • America’s poorest families spend 22% of their household budgets on utilities and gas. By comparison, families in the top income quintile only spend 5% of their household budgets on these same expenses. Rising energy prices hit low-income families harder. 
  • In New England, moratoriums on natural gas extraction, and pipeline transport from Pennsylvania and Ohio caused electricity price increases that were double that of similar regions across the country.  
  • In 2019, as a result of fracking and increased natural gas production, the U.S. reduced CO2 emissions by 140 million tonnes, the largest reduction of any country according to the International Energy Agency. 
  • Because of fracking U.S. emissions have outpaced the rest of the world.  According to the EPA, from 2005 to 2018, total U.S. energy-related CO2 emissions fell by 12 percent, while global energy-related emissions increased nearly 24 percent during this period.  
  • Abroad, the Green New Deal and similar plans would make our allies more dependent on bad actors and rogue states like Russia, Iran, and Venezuela for their energy needs. Domestically, outlawing fossil fuels would degrade our ability to rely upon our own natural resources as we make the switch from reliable energy to unreliable or unproven “green” techs.

Please also see additional information on PAYGO exemptions, courtesy of the House Committee on Rules Republicans, here.